Elected Police Chief: Product of Personal Resentment and Confusing Ballot Wording

Looking back at the history of the elected police chief in Santa Clara and why the initial City Charter was changed to switch to an elected chief.

“We’ve always done it this way” is the principal argument being offered for retaining Santa Clara’s system of electing police chiefs and requiring no qualifications beyond living in the city, graduating from high school and four years of law enforcement experience. But we haven’t always done it this way. Further, the way we do it … Read more

Point – Counterpoint: Measure B, City of Santa Clara

Members of the Yes on Measure B and No on Measure B campaigns explain their stances on the issue of elected vs. appointed police chief.

One of the biggest issues facing the City of Santa Clara on the March 5 is Measure B – a ballot measure designed to change the City’s Charter and make the position of police chief appointed by the city manager instead of the current system in which the chief is elected. Because this is a … Read more

Judge Denies Challenge to Police Chief Ballot Measure

Judge denied a request that Santa Clara change the wording of Measure B which asks voters to decide whether the police chief should be appointed.

The trio that sued Santa Clara over the text of a ballot measure on appointing the city’s police chief — Measure B — got coal in their Christmas stocking this week when Santa Clara Superior Court Judge Thomas Kuhnle denied their eleventh-hour request to change the ballot text. The petitioners brought their case on Dec. … Read more

Proposed Ballot Measures to Appoint Police Chief, City Clerk Go Before Council

The Charter Review Committee has recommended that Santa Clara vote on whether to make the police chief and city clerk positions elected.

The 2023 Santa Clara Charter review committee wrapped up its work on Oct. 17, finalizing its recommendation for two ballot measures to change the positions of city clerk and police chief to appointments by the city manager from the present election system. If the city council approves the recommendation, the measures to change the city … Read more

Charter Review Committee Meeting: Appointed City Clerk and Police Chief Don’t Feel Intimidated

Santa Clara's Charter Review Committee heard from an appointed city clerk in Los Gatos and a retired police chief from Mountain View.

At its third meeting on Sept. 14, the 2023 Santa Clara Charter Review Committee heard from Los Gatos appointed City Clerk Wendy Wood and retired Mountain View Police Chief Max Bosel. The committee asked both speakers if they ever felt intimidated by the fact that they could be fired at any moment. Santa Clara City … Read more

Charter Review Committee Survey Out Now

The City of Santa Clara has released a community survey to gauge public opinion on whether the police chief and city clerk should be appointed positions.

Santa Clara has released a citywide survey to help the 2023 Charter Review Committee make an informed decision about whether or not to change the city charter in regard to how the City selects its police chief and city clerk. The survey is just ten questions long. It includes questions on city of residence and … Read more

2023 Charter Review Committee Hears from Police Chief, City Clerk

The second meeting of the 2023 Charter Review Committee included comments from City Clerk Hosam Haggag and Police Chief Pat Nikolai.

The Aug. 24 meeting of the Charter Review Committee was an opportunity for the committee and the public to hear from and ask questions of the City’s elected police chief and city clerk. Both City Clerk Hosam Haggag and Police Chief Pat Nikolai were present. The public comment was fairly evenly split between those who … Read more